Thursday, October 13, 2011

Part 1: Digital Learning Now's National Report Card on virtual Education Movement


You definitely need a score card to follow the grading system Digital Learning Now used for its first National Report Card on digital education.
The state-by-state look at the status of digital learning, and the assignment of "grades" to each state is based on 72 metrics developed by Digital Learning Now. These metrics are based on DLN's "10 Elements of High Quality Digital Learning."  These elements,  published last year, were used as the foundation for virtual education legislation from Idaho to Florida. In fact, the 2010 Florida virtual education law was called "The Digital Learning Now Act."
Numbers are used to provide a quick view of how DLN sizes up a state--0 is the low, 10 is the high.
DLN also uses labels to characterize the standing of each state when it comes to meeting DLN's "10 Elements." These "levels of attainment" are:
Achieved: indicates that the state has adopted the measure through law, rule or
indisputable practice.
Partial: indicates the entire range of policies and circumstances between Not Yet and Achieved.
Not Yet: indicates that the state has no policy, a permissive policy that is not effectively achieving the vision or a policy that conflicts with the measure.
If any of this analysis is in dispute, governors and state school chiefs will have until Dec. 31 to challenge DLN's findings.
Why all the emphasis on digital learning. The "Roadmap to Reform," DLN released today says it all.
"Digital learning ensures students are never bored and never left behind. Students who excel in a subject can move ahead academically. Conversely, students who are struggling in a particular subject can spend extra time mastering those skills with guidance from their teacher – either remotely or face-to-face. In schools that adopt blended learning, these students can remain in the same class as their peers even as their individual learning takes them on different paths."
There are some cool features to the online version of the report card. By clicking individual states, the viewer can compare several the results of several states next to each other.
That said, Liberating Learning Twitter followers asked that the results of these states be spotlighted first: California, Missouri, New York, Montana and North Carolina.  Here goes:
California: The Golden State is not so golden when it comes to digital learning. Numeric grades ranged from 0-4. The state received more "not yets" (for example, private school students are eligible for publicly-funded digital learning, home education students are eligible for publicly-funded digital learning, State law ensures publicly-funded digital learning is available for all middle school students) than "achieved" (under state law, district public school students are eligible for publicly-funded digital learning, under state law, charter public school students are eligible for publicly-funded digital learning). DLN researchers added that the state "should repeal regulations that limit online schools to contiguous counties to allow online learning to flourish and expand."
Missouri: Missouri numeric scores run the gamut from 1-10. For infrastructure ("Infrastructure supports digital learning"), 1. But the state received a 10 for "quality of choices" ("All students have access to multiple high quality digital learning providers"). The researchers added the "Missouri has a statewide program for individual online courses from multiple providers, Missouri Virtual Instruction Program.  The program is currently funded by a very low line-item appropriation for students who are medically fragile.  Missouri could exponentially expand its digital learning options by requiring school districts to provide unfettered access to
individual online courses offered by program using existing funding through the per pupil funding formula."
New York: Like so many other states, DLN's researchers wrote that New York has the opportunity to be a leader in the edtech revolution. So far, well, New York's  DLN numeric scores were all three and below. The state got deserved credit for abandoning seat-time rules when it comes to digital courses, but more often than not, the "not yet" label was attached to the survey's metrics. Finally, the reviewers did give a nod to iLearnNYC, which they said, "is offering online and blended courses within the nation’s largest school district."
Montana: Results from this state are a mixed bag. Montana does not authorize charter schools. It does not have a state-led virtual school. But private school and home-schooled students are eligible for publicly-funded digital learning. This is probably the reason Montana's highest numeric score, 5, was for "student access," that is the ability for all students in the state to be "digital learners." The researchers added: "Montana can expand digital learning by opening the state to more providers of digital learning,
including charter schools."
North Carolina: North Carolina has the second largest state virtual school. That would make one think that the state would be in the top echelon of states. According to the DLN research, that's not the case. Digital education "growth slowed this year with the switch from line-item funding to money-follows-the-students," according the researchers. "Removing the ability for school districts to deny access and requiring students to take an online course for graduation could jumpstart enrollment." North Carolina's numeric rankings range from 0-4. There are more "not yet" ranking than "achieved." The researchers did find a bright spot, "a growing number of districts are adding online and blended options."
Stay tuned for Part 2, coming later this afternoon, of this report when five more states will be spotlighted.




No comments:

Post a Comment