Thursday, October 20, 2011

It's a Flipping Controversy

EdSurge got it right. There is a growing debate over the flipped classroom model and it is fascinating to watch this controversy grow.
First, a definition. The Flip Model is being championed by Sal Khan, a former hedge fund analyst who became an accidental education entrepreneur when algebra videos he made to help some cousins went viral.
A flipped approach features a video lecture that the student can watch "any time, any where," let's say at home in place of  traditional homework assignments. This frees classroom time for the teacher to work with individual students or for students to work in teams.
In a article for Education Next, Bill Tucker, managing editor of Education Sector quotes Colorado chemistry teacher Jonathan Bergmann about the flipped method.
"Flipped classroom teachers almost universally agree that it’s not the instructional videos on their own, but how they are integrated into an overall approach, that makes the difference. In his classes, Bergmann says, students can’t just 'watch the video and be done with it.' He checks their notes and requires each student to come to class with a question. And, while he says it takes a little while for students to get used to the system, as the year progresses he sees them asking better questions and thinking more deeply about the
content. After flipping his classroom, Bergmann says he can more easily query individual students, probe for misconceptions around scientific concepts, and clear up incorrect notions."
So why is the flipped method so controversial? Some flip opponents worry about the digital divide.
"Uruguay ranks ahead of the United States in laptop distribution. Maine is the only state to make a significant investment toward ensuring all students even have the computer technology they'd need to watch videos at home. And even giving students laptops doesn't mean they can access the Internet at home. With poverty skyrocketing, some families simply can't afford it," writes Liz Dwyer, education editor of website GOOD.
Dwyer also says, "The other element left out of the flipped classroom discussion is that watching a video is no more active or engaging than reading a textbook. And what happens when a high school student is assigned videos from all six of her classes? Do we really expect students to watch two or three hours of videos at night?"
Vancouver, B.C. teacher David Wees tried the flipped method and decided to drop it.
"Some students chose, despite repeated requests from me, to only watch videos and do exercises that were really easy for them, instead of advancing their knowledge. One student said 'she liked the easy videos because it was easy to get points.' Another student said she chose the easy exercises because 'she was worried about getting problems wrong.' These students were more focused on getting easy
points and avoiding challenges than learning," Wees writes.
Indiana teacher Brian Bennett argues that the flipped method isn't just about the videos.
"The flipped classroom is about making connections with learners and differentiating your instruction. If videos are a part of that multi-faceted plan, great. If they are not, still great. The flipped class is an ideology, not a methodology," Bennett writes.
Bill Tucker, in his Education Next article, seems to summarize the feeling of the moment best.
"Given education’s long history of fascination with new instructional approaches that are later abandoned, there’s a real danger that flipping, a seemingly simple idea that is profound in practice, may be reduced into the latest educational fad. And, in today’s highly polarized political environment, it also runs the risk of being falsely pigeonholed into one of education’s many false dichotomies, such as the age-old pedagogical debate between content knowledge and skills acquisition."

No comments:

Post a Comment