Tuesday, November 29, 2011

Flipped Classroom: A Pro/Con Debate


There is passion on both sides of the Flipped Classroom Debate.
For the uninitiated, the flipped classroom concept was made popular by Sal Kahn, the hedge fund analyst turned edu-preneur. Kahn's view is that students used view a video lecture at home for homework and use classroom time for one-on-one time with the teacher or group projects.
Proponents of the flipped classroom see this as a way to combine the best of technology and the best of traditional classroom methods. "It not only can, but has changed the lives of many students," writes Jon Bergmann, who, according to EdRech.us, is a pioneer of the flipped classroom movement.
Not so fast, counter flipped classroom skeptics.
"While I certainly see the benefits in flipping instruction," writes Lisa Nielsen for Tech & Learning, "there are also reasons to move ahead with caution."
Click here to read more of Bergmann's post, "The Flipped Classroom Revisited."
Click here to read more of Nielson's post, "Five Reasons I'm not Flipping Over the Flipped Classroom."

Monday, November 21, 2011

Crisis with State Budgets Turns into Crisis for Funding Virtual Education


An interesting trend is rippling across the United State and it is hurting the progress of online learning.
When state budgets are being trimmed, money is being taken away from virtual education programs.
Let's start with Delaware. In 2008, Delaware launched the Delaware Virtual School as a pilot program. It offered six online courses through 27 high schools and serving nearly 300 students. But as Delaware legislators grappled with falling revenues, the virtual school’s budget was eliminated.
 A limited version of the pilot program continued through the 2008-2009 school year, but then came an $800 million state budget deficit. The program did not receive funding for 2009-2010 school year. Ditto for the 2010-2011 school year.
Missouri is in a similar situation. Missouri looked as if it would be a leader in developing statewide online learning programs. That all changed in 2009.
A state fiscal crisis led legislators to take away most money from online learning initiatives. For the 2009-2010 school year, the legislature appropriate $4.8 million for the Missouri Virtual Instruction Program (MoVIP). This was a decrease of 17%.
MoVIP course enrollments dropped 82% from 15,810 in 2008-2009 to 2,900 in 2009-2010.  What's more, to meet budget constraints, and to accommodate the demand for courses, MoVIP  temporarily limited the number of courses a student can enroll in to five from six.
Additionally, the Missouri Virtual school closed at the end of the 2009-2010 school year. A few months later, 45 teachers who lost their jobs in the fall of 2009 when the state cut funding for MoVIIP. They claimed contracts guaranteed them positions with MoVIP for a full year.
Earlier this year in Texas, the state legislature cut funding to the Texas Virtual School Network. The result: enrollment in the network is down to about 1,700 students this fall to around 1,300 students. Texas districts are scrambling to find money to create their own virtual education programs.


Thursday, November 10, 2011

iNACOL Report on International K-12 Online Learning: Everybody's Doing It


This is supposed to be the big week for the annual  "Keeping Pace with  K-12 Online Learning "report. So far, that's the way it's turned out.
But attention must be paid to the International Association for K-12 Online Learning's (iNACOL) second international survey of blended and online learning programs. If you need proof that virtual education is an international movement, you must read "Online and Blended Learning: A Survey of Policy and Practice of K-12 Schools around the World."
In 2006, the first time iNACOL conducted this international study of online learning around the world, researchers sent surveys to over 60 countries and received 17 responses
For the 2011 report, 60 surveys were sent and iNACOL received a total of 50 completed surveys.
An impressive increase in participation which suggests that something really is happening here.
"Capitalizing on widely embraced digital tools, the landscape of the 21st century classroom will be markedly different than any time in history. The World Future Society predicts that learning will become more personalized, less delineated between seat time and free time, with greater implementation of gaming and social networking. At 800 million users—75 percent of which reside outside the United States—Facebook proves that trend already exists outside of the classroom. The onus is on national and school-level leaders to tap into the potential that digital learning provides," according to the researchers.
"The ramifications of digital access to superior education for all students in every country are profound; highly educated citizens will impact the global, knowledge-based economy," they added.
The report is 130 pages of clearly written research and chock full of examples. Highlights and challenges of virtual education equally share the spotlight in this report.
Particularly interesting is the section which breaks down the status of online learning nation by nation. From Kosovo to Brazil, from Botswana to Singapore, iNACOL's report captures what is fast-becoming a worldwide movement.

Sunday, November 6, 2011

Legislative and Market Successes Round Out Keeping Pace's Top Trends


The impact of Digital Learning Now on the legislative process. The intersection of Common Core Standards and virtual eduction. The growth of start-up companies and "edu-preneurs" in providing online learning products. Increased focus on online learning and special needs students.
These are the trends that researchers for the annual Keeping Pace with K-12 Learning unveiled in the days before the entire report is issued.
While all these trends are notable, and have a direct impact on the continued growth and acceptance of virtual education, probably the most impressive direction is the number of states that adopted new virtual education laws.
The Keeping Pace researchers reported that 16 states passed online learning laws. "New online learning legislation in Florida, Utah, Idaho, Ohio, and Wisconsin will change the education landscape in those states in coming years," according to the sneak peek at the full report.
The blog post also noted that many of the states cited Digital Learning Now's "Ten Elements of High Quality Digital Learning" in the laws. Florida even named it's law the "Digital Learning Now Act."
The new players entering the market to provide virtual education software, curriculum, management services and more is another important milestone. Entrepreneurs see virtual education as an expanding, and profitable, arena. Additionally, the provider landscape changed with the acquisition of some of the long-time independents, such as Pearson's $400 million purchase of Connections Academy.
Liberating Learning will provide more analysis and try to put the Keeping Pace research in context in the upcoming week.

Friday, November 4, 2011

Khan Academy to get Physical


Everybody's talking about how Khan Academy just secured a $5 million grant.
But that's not the big news.
Khan Academy is going to open a bricks-and-mortar school somewhere in Northern California (probably in Silicon Valley's Mountain View or Los Altos area) in summer 2012.
Hello blended learning experiment.
According to TechCrunch, "the physical school ... will be run as a series of summer school camps."
"The camp will be a testing ground for curricula that will, over time, develop into a complete academic experience and serve as a model for real-world schools worldwide," TechCrunch quotes Khan.
In the press release announcing the $5 million grant, Khan states:
"The school of the future will not resemble the school of today. In the past, the assembly-line, lecture-homework-exam model existed because that's what was possible in the no-tech and low-tech classrooms of their day."
In case you do not know Salman Khan, he is the former hedge fund analyst who who turned a series of YouTube videos about algebra created to help tutor his cousins into a free, online education platform and nonprofit organization.
Khan has tested his idea of "flipped' curriculum--that is lectures on video, in-class teaching time spent on individual instruction and group projects--in several Silicon Valley schools.
In addition to the $5 million from the O'Sullivan Foundation, Khan Academy raised more than $2 million from Google and The Gates Foundation.
Part of the O'Sullivan money will go to expanding the Khan Academy curriculum and to hiring faculty. Previously, Khan's subject focus was on math, science and engineering. These are areas Khan feels comfortable with since he has  math and science degrees from MIT and a Harvard MBA. Additionally, Khan was Khan Academy's only instructor.
The new funding will allow the Khan Academy to expand into the arts and the humanities and to add faculty.
For all of Khan Academy's success, there are some critics. Audrey Watters of Hack Education posted this recently.
"No doubt, Khan has done something incredible by creating thousands of videos, distributing them online for free, and now designing an analytics dashboard for people to monitor and guide students’ movements through the Khan Academy material. And no doubt, lots of people say they’ve learned a lot by watching the videos. The ability pause, rewind, and replay is often cited as the difference between 'getting'  the subject matter through classroom instruction and 'getting it' via Khan Academy’s lecture-demonstrations," Watters wrote.
"But that’s the crux of the problem right there: lecture-demonstrations. Although there’s a tech component here that makes this appear innovative, that’s really a matter of form, not content, that’s new. There’s actually very little in one of the videos that distinguishes Khan from 'traditional' teaching. A teacher talks. Students listen. And that’s 'learning.' Repeat over and over again (Pause, rewind, replay in this case). And that’s 'drilling,' " she added.

Tuesday, November 1, 2011

Keeping Pace: It is the Best of Times, the Worst of Times for State-Led Virtual Schools


The folks behind the annual compendium on the state of K-12 online education in the United State, the Evergreen Education Group's Keeping Pace with K-12 Online Learning, continue to tease us with findings from their 2010-2011 report, which is scheduled to be unveiled on Nov. 8.
Some of the early revelations have been astonishing. There is more expansion of online learning opportunities in school districts than at the state level (a true reversal of fortune); and that these school districts are developing more blended learning programs than pure virtual education programs.
Other of the teasers released by the Keeping Pace researchers aren't so dramatic. Regional education organizations such as county offices of education, public-private partnerships, are increasing their roles in developing and expanding online programs; and more states have full-time online schools (thanks to new laws on the books in states such as Tennessee and Indiana).
But the most recent trend announced by Keeping Pace is one of the most noteworthy. State-led virtual schools, the researchers report, are " diverging into two tiers."
"While 40 states have a state virtual school or similar state-led initiative, these programs are increasingly falling into two divergent categories: those that are sustainably funded at a level to have a real impact on their states, and those that do not have a level of reliable support," Keeping Pace researchers wrote.
"States in the former category include Florida, North Carolina, Michigan, Montana, Idaho, and Alabama. Other state programs are in decline, mostly due to funding cuts. These include programs in Maryland, Missouri, and California," the authors added.
The future of state-led virtual schools was placed under the microscope earlier this year when Bryan Setser, vice president for advisory services for Open Education Solutions, speculated on the future of these once disruptive innovations.
"Are state-led virtual schools in trouble? I pondered this question quite a bit when I resigned my post as CEO of the North Carolina Virtual Public School in April. Three reasons led to my decision and continue to fuel my advisory work for Open Education Solutions," Sester wrote.
Setser's questions: Can state-led virtual schools be nimble? Can choice coexist with competent and creative curators? Can state virtual schools get out of their own way?
The Keeping Pace researchers ended their glimpse of their state-led virtual school findings on a positive note. "All state virtual schools together accounted for 536,000 course enrollments (one student taking one semester-long course) in SY 2010-11, an annual increase of 19%."
Click here to read more on Setser's take on the future of virtual schools.
Click here to read more on some of the trends Keeping Pace researchers will unveil next week.