Friday, February 10, 2012

When it Comes to Virtual Education, School Districts are now Leading the Way


What started as a drip, a school district here, a school district there, has turned into a deluge. From the Oregon Coast to the valleys of Pennsylvania, from the Treasure Coast of Florida to the rural school districts in the fabled "Four Corners," where Arizona, New Mexico, Utah and Colorado meet, to Iowa, school districts across the United States are launching online learning programs.
They are doing this, if for no other reason, in self defense.
The action taken by the Pennsylvania's Salisbury Township School Board, which serves an 11.3 square mile district  outside the city of Allentown and serves about 1,800 students, is a good example of why so many school districts are starting their own virtual education programs.
In February, the school board approved creation of the  Virtual Academy of Salisbury Township, or VAST. The reason: to "win back students and the nearly half-million dollars in tuition (the district sends) to cyber and other charter schools," according to the Salisbury Patch.
The local virtual school is scheduled to in August 2012.
School district's throughout Pennsylvania are launching their own virtual schools because of the revenue they are losing to cyber charter schools. In 2011, Pennsylvania Auditor General Jack Wagner called for a moratorium of creation of new cyber charter schools, which are allowed to enroll students from throughout the state. He said no new cyber charters should be authorized until a new method of allocating state education funds, one that would not be so burdensome to local district, was in place.
Since then, the Pennsylvania legislature has tried and tried again to come up with a bill that would change how the state funds cyber charter schools.
So far, no bill has made it through both houses of the legislature. Not willing to wait, Pennsylvania districts are launching their own virtual schools to compete with the statewide cyber charters.
For example, this year the Erie school district will pay  almost $2.25 million for 248 students to attend online charter schools, primarily the Pennsylvania Cyber Charter School and Agora Cyber Charter School.
"We can sit back and lament that fact, or as the charter law intended, we can be competitive," Erie schools Superintendent Jay Badams said. "And we feel we have a product that will be extremely competitive."
So, earlier this year, Erie announced the creation the Erie Public Schools Online Campus. The new program will offer online courses to students at the district's four high schools
Badams said creating the online school is a move to keep Erie tax dollars in Erie.
The story is a little different in Florida. In 2011, the "Digital Learning Now Act" allowed individual school district to strike deals with K-12 online curriculum providers. This meant that school districts could create their own virtual charter or virtual schools in competition to the state-led Florida Virtual School.
Online learning advocates quickly brought proposals before school board. The results have been mixed.
Earlier this year, the Miami-Dade School Board rejected proposals for four new virtual charter schools. According to the Miami Herald, district staff staff concluded that the four schools’ applications did not meet school district standards or the state law for virtual schools. The staff found that the charter schools failed to show how they would offer off-line help to students, and how they would communicate with parents, according to a district memo.
The staff also objected to the 50-to-1 student-to-teacher ratio proposed for the online classes at some of the schools, and questioned how the schools would provide services to students with special needs, or students who are learning English.
But virtual charter schools are not going away:  According to the Miami Herald, the school district will have to review several more applications in the coming months.
In Florida's so-called Treasure Coast, which includes the counties of  Martin, St. Lucie, Indian River and Okeechobee, discussions are being held by the four counties about combining resources and creating online learning programs to serves all the students in the region.
"This is a bold, innovative and ambitious effort being undertaken by the school districts. There is cause for optimism the effort will be successful," according to an editorial in the Treasure Coast Palm. "the effort sets an example for other governmental bodies throughout the Treasure Coast to consider to improve services and programs for their constituents on a regional basis."
Money, at least attracting more federal funding, may be a reason several Oregon school districts are launching hybrid or blended learning programs. District officials say they could be eligible for up to $500,000 in federal money if their districts launch hybrid charters schools.
In Portage, Wisc., the school board has approved plans to launch a virtual school in fall 2012.
"I think this is going to be a springboard for students ... it's time," said Kristen Skolarz, vice president of the Portage School Board.
Liberating Learning Blog contributor Tom Vander Ark agrees. "Every school district needs an innovation agenda, a five-year plan that brings the benefits of personal digital learning to every student. The challenge for school leaders is to find the right balance of execution and innovation -- running a good school today and phasing in the future.

Wednesday, February 1, 2012

Highlights from Digital Learning Day


Maine Gov. Paul LePage issued an executive order directing  his education commissioner on  to develop a plan that increases online learning opportunities for Maine’s K-12 students.
LePage's order came on Digital Learning Day. A coincidence? Doubtful.
LePage and Maine's Education Commissioner Stephen Bowen are supporters of digital education and what better day to get set online learning expansion goals than on the first National Digital Learning Day.
From sea to shining sea, there were lots of events to mark Digital Learning Day.
In Alabama, students in Etowah County schools showed off how digital equipment is  “the spoonful of sugar” that helps learning vocabulary go down.
The International Association for K-12 Online Learning (iNACOL) noted  the day by focusing on the policies that will help expand online education.
"Outdated state policies still tie the hands of many school districts, and block the fundamental reforms necessary for truly transformation next-generation learning, Susan Patrick, president and chief executive of iNACOL said. "States need a roadmap for change so they can accelerate the achievement of world-class educational standards for all students, regardless of socioeconomic status, geography or other limitations."
Many teachers groups got on the Digital Learning Day bandwagon. For example, the National Council of Teachers of English provided its members with resources to bring digital learning to their classrooms and show how to use "technology to strengthen the student learning experience."
Liberating Learning Blog contributor Tom Vander Ark was in Ohio where is testified before the Ohio House of Representatives Committee On Education. The committee was holding a hearing on digital learning.
"Over the next few years most American schools will provide students with access devices, shift to predominantly digital instructional materials, give tests online, and support teachers with powerful tools.  They will blend the best of online and onsite learning to boost achievement," Vander Ark said.
" Ohio should remove barriers to digital learning including class size ratios, and seat time requirements.  The state should make sure students and families understand their learning options. To remain relevant, certification should be performance based with well-supported alternative pathways.  Online resources should be provides for Ohio’s teachers," he added.
Even the New York Times, whose coverage of online learning in recent months has become a bone of contention within the virtual education community, took time to "Celebrate Digital Learning Day with 40 Years of Times EdTech Reporting."
West Virginia, Wisconsin, and Arizona are just a few of the states where attention was paid to Digital Learning Day.
"Digital Learning Day is more than just a day," said former West Virginia Gov. Bob Wise whose Alliance for Excellent Education started the Digital Learning Day ball rolling. "It is about building a digital learning movement that provides teachers with better tools to truly provide a quality education for every child.
"Effective technology combined with great teachers and engaged students have the potential to transform the world of learning," he added.

Monday, January 30, 2012

A Preview of Digital Learning Day


The numbers are impressive. Thirty-seven states and the District of Columbia have signed on to participate. More than 10,000 teachers and 1.7 million students have raised their hands in support.
All for the first of what many hope will be an annual Digital Learning Day.
"Passionate education advocates have banded together—from classrooms, schools, districts, local communities, states, nonprofit organizations, foundations, and corporations—to rally around an issue that is critically important to both the nation’s students and America’s economic well-being for generations to come," former West Virginia Gov. Bob Wise, whose Alliance for Excellent Education launched the idea for Digital Learning Day, wrote for USA Today's Teachers' Lounge website.
"This is a celebration of teachers and administrators who are using technology as a force multiplier for good teaching practice that raises student outcomes. Through the Digital Learning Day campaign, the Alliance hopes teachers will be empowered to try something new using their talents and expertise to create challenging and effective learning environments for every child in their classroom," Wise added.
What can we expect on Digital Learning Day? Well, in Los Angeles, the Partnership for Los Angeles Schools will announce an  "innovative blended learning strategy across its network of schools followed by a media tour of classrooms to showcase blended learning in action at Dolores Huerta Elementary School.
The Partnership was founded in 2007 and is part of Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa’s plan to improve education in Los Angeles. It is a collaboration between the City of Los Angeles and the Los Angeles Unified School District to turn around LA’s lowest performing schools. The Partnership manages 22 schools with nearly 17,000 students and 1,500 employees.
"By bringing technology into the classroom we are providing students with the kind of invaluable exposure to technology they need to compete in today’s technologically advanced job market. But technology alone isn’t enough, which is why we are undergoing an aggressive blended learning strategy that couples rigorous teaching tools that engage and inspire with teacher training and tailored instruction," said Marshall Tuck, chief executive of the Partnership.
Over in Ohio, Digital Learning Day will be a day-long celebration that will feature Liberating Learning Blog contributor Tom Vander Ark and include testimony before an Ohio House of Representatives Education Committee.
According to KnowledgeWorks, a Cincinnati-based social enterprise that supports innovative education initiatives, Vander Ark and Lisa Duty, director of external affairs for KnowledgeWorks, will testify before
Education Committee of the Ohio House of Representatives on digital learning issues. Vander Ark will also participate in a book chat at The Ohio State University College of Education and Human Ecology and the Ohio Resource Center. Later in the evening, Vander Ark will speak at a reception sponsored by several online learning advocacy groups including eTech Ohio.
Kansas plans to release the results of statewide survey on digital learning on Feb. 1. Wisconsin will release its statewide digital learning plan. And in Michigan, Digital Learning Day will be used as part of the kick-off of the state's "Year of the Digital Learner."
"As we approach this day, and as district schools, charter schools, and states around the country participate, we must make sure that this doesn't become a day that is all about technology for technology’s sake," Michael. B. Horn, a Liberating Learning Blog contributor wrote.
"The critical thing is to fashion a student-centric system powered by digital learning that allows each child to realize his or her fullest human potential. Technology in this vision becomes the backbone that helps us to customize an education for each child’s unique learning needs, not the gadget that’s just there because it’s cool or because we simply think learning through or with technology is the way we should do it now," he added.
At the center of this national celebration of digital learning will be two virtual gatherings. The Alliance for Excellent Education will host a webcast featuring moderated videos and discussion on innovation,instruction strategies and professional development opportunities.
The webcast will feature schools and educators from North Carolina to California, form Colorado to Texas.
At 1 p.m. Eastern, there will be a virtual National Town Hall on digital learning, featuring Federal Communication Chairman Julius Genachowski and U.S. Secretary of Education Arne Duncan.
Links for the webcast and the town hall will be posted on Liberating Learning.

Monday, January 16, 2012

What People are Saying about Fordham's 'The Cost of Online Learning'


It's for good reason the virtual education movement paused and took notice of the early January release of "The Cost of Online Learning."
For one thing, this is the Fordham Institute's third in a series of papers that look at the online learning movement.  These reports focus on the policies of the virtual education movement and provide guideposts that could help the movement grow.
Secondly, the issue of how much does--and should--online learning cost, especially when compared to a bricks-and-mortar education, is a big issue. 
In many instances, online learning has been sold to policy makers as a less-expensive alternative to traditional education. This has made virtual and digital alternatives attractive to  lawmakers in cash-strapped states. These policy makers want to provide a quality education to all children, but want to do it a rock-bottom cost.
But as online learning makes faster in-roads into public education, non-profit and for-profit providers are saying that a quality education still needs a reasonable financial foundation. Lawmakers have been surprised that that financial foundation is more than they expected.
That's why Fordham's "The Cost of Online Learning" gained so much attention so quickly. It is one of the first research papers to set the funding bar. 
Liberating Learning Blog contributor Tom Vander Ark was one of the first online learning thought leaders to weigh in with an opinion on the Fordham paper. 
"Online learning providers won't agree with the projected 35% savings. They would say that with staffing ratios not all that different from traditional schools there is some opportunity for cost savings -- maybe half of what" the researchers came up with, Vander Ark wrote.
"Real costs also depend a lot on the clients. It may cost twice as much to serve over-aged and under-credited youth with multiple risk factors than it does to serve motivated well-supported students," he continued..
"The real cost of producing college and career ready graduates depends on the student population and the risk factors they bring to school," Vander Ark added.
In Education Sector Managing Editor Bill Tucker's blog, "The Quick & The Ed," he wrote that "while  the paper cannot offer definitive answers for policymakers and school leaders, it does provide a helpful primer on the overall economics of online and blended learning."
"The author’s cost figures reflect estimates of what online and blended schools are currently spending, rather than what they should be spending. In other words, since we have little understanding of how spending relates to student outcomes, the authors cannot say much about either the effectiveness or productivity of this spending. Is it the right amount? We just don’t know," Tucker wrote.
Susan Patrick , president and chief executive the International Association for K-12 Online Learning (iNACOL), called the report "a serious effort to look into the cost driers for online and blended programs." 
But Patrick also issued a warning.
"In any case, claims that per-student costs (included in the research report)  could approach these numbers could be dangerous, because they may encourage school districts and other authorities looking for online learning solutions to sacrifice the quality of education for cost," Patrick wrote.  "The largest costs in online learning programs, blended learning programs and traditional education programs are faculty and people.  So while important funding decisions do need to be made, these decisions must reflect a better understanding of the cost drivers and the 'average costs' necessary to provide high-quality and cost-efficient online education for all students with people providing support.  Online and blended learning can help students access the best teachers to provide personalized instruction to meet individual student needs."Overall, the focus of our efforts should be on student outcomes, results and success.  State legislators and education policymakers should work to ensure that not only does their funding enable them to provide students with the opportunity to learn online, but also that it provides every student with the opportunity to access a world-class education," Patrick concluded.

Monday, January 2, 2012

Legislative and Virtual Education Policy Outlook for 2012


If 2011 was any indication, 2012 will be a busy year for the online learning community.
This week, state legislatures from Kentucky to California, from Massachusetts, New Hampshire and New York to Missouri, Pennsylvania and back to Rhode Island, will open legislative sessions that may become one of the busiest sessions for virtual education advocates.
Here is a breakdown of a few states, including the District of Columbia, and the issues that are sure to surface in to the upcoming year.
Unfinished Business
--Michigan: The House has yet to vote on lifting cap on virtual schools. Action is expected sometime in January.
--Pennsylvania: State legislature has yet to come up with a funding plan for cyber charter schools. While the legislature debates, individual school districts are developing, and launching, their own cyber schools as a way to retain students, and state funding.
--Tennessee: Lots has been made of the way this state funded its first virtual charter school. The relationship between the Union County School District and K12 Inc. has attracted national attention. Expect the Tennessee legislature to revisit on virtual schools are funded.
-- Idaho: A tumultuous battle to get an edtech-center reform package, including Idaho becoming the nation's first state to require that students take two online courses in order to graduate from high school, isn't over. Opponents to the reforms obtained enough signatures to place a referendum to repeal the plan on the November ballot. Expect another knock-down battle leading to the fall vote.
Gubernatorial Promises
In 2011, governors in these states promised to expand online learning opportunities. Nevada Gov. Brian Sandoval was one of the governors making such a pledge, however the Nevada legislature does not have a regular session scheduled for 2012.
--Nebraska
--New Mexico
--New Jersey
Devil in the Detail
These states passed historic virtual education legislation in 2011. This year, full implementation will start. Many will be watching to see what happens.
--Utah
--Indiana
--Florida
Primed for Change
These states, among others, are the ones to watch for legislative debate and action on expanding online opportunities.
--Kentucky
--New York
--Massachusetts
--Oregon
Worth Watching
--Florida: The county-level/school district debate over creation of cyber charter schools has already started. Some charters have been approved. Other plans have been rejected. The policy of allowing school district to individually authorize and launch their own cyber charters was part of the 2011 "Digital Learning Now Act." This grass-root movement is definitely worth watching.
--California: This state has been a backwater in the virtual education community. Here's why things may change in 2012:

  •     A petition drive to place an initiative on the ballot that would expand online learning opportunities in the state.
  •     A plan to revive a bill that would allow state education funding to follow the student, no matter what public school choice the student makes.
  •     The chance for Rocketship Education to show that its blended learning network is scalable (Rocketship Education became the largest charter school operator in Silicon Valley in late 2011. It also has a handshake agreement with the District of Columbia schools chief to create eight schools in the nation's capital.)