Monday, January 16, 2012

What People are Saying about Fordham's 'The Cost of Online Learning'


It's for good reason the virtual education movement paused and took notice of the early January release of "The Cost of Online Learning."
For one thing, this is the Fordham Institute's third in a series of papers that look at the online learning movement.  These reports focus on the policies of the virtual education movement and provide guideposts that could help the movement grow.
Secondly, the issue of how much does--and should--online learning cost, especially when compared to a bricks-and-mortar education, is a big issue. 
In many instances, online learning has been sold to policy makers as a less-expensive alternative to traditional education. This has made virtual and digital alternatives attractive to  lawmakers in cash-strapped states. These policy makers want to provide a quality education to all children, but want to do it a rock-bottom cost.
But as online learning makes faster in-roads into public education, non-profit and for-profit providers are saying that a quality education still needs a reasonable financial foundation. Lawmakers have been surprised that that financial foundation is more than they expected.
That's why Fordham's "The Cost of Online Learning" gained so much attention so quickly. It is one of the first research papers to set the funding bar. 
Liberating Learning Blog contributor Tom Vander Ark was one of the first online learning thought leaders to weigh in with an opinion on the Fordham paper. 
"Online learning providers won't agree with the projected 35% savings. They would say that with staffing ratios not all that different from traditional schools there is some opportunity for cost savings -- maybe half of what" the researchers came up with, Vander Ark wrote.
"Real costs also depend a lot on the clients. It may cost twice as much to serve over-aged and under-credited youth with multiple risk factors than it does to serve motivated well-supported students," he continued..
"The real cost of producing college and career ready graduates depends on the student population and the risk factors they bring to school," Vander Ark added.
In Education Sector Managing Editor Bill Tucker's blog, "The Quick & The Ed," he wrote that "while  the paper cannot offer definitive answers for policymakers and school leaders, it does provide a helpful primer on the overall economics of online and blended learning."
"The author’s cost figures reflect estimates of what online and blended schools are currently spending, rather than what they should be spending. In other words, since we have little understanding of how spending relates to student outcomes, the authors cannot say much about either the effectiveness or productivity of this spending. Is it the right amount? We just don’t know," Tucker wrote.
Susan Patrick , president and chief executive the International Association for K-12 Online Learning (iNACOL), called the report "a serious effort to look into the cost driers for online and blended programs." 
But Patrick also issued a warning.
"In any case, claims that per-student costs (included in the research report)  could approach these numbers could be dangerous, because they may encourage school districts and other authorities looking for online learning solutions to sacrifice the quality of education for cost," Patrick wrote.  "The largest costs in online learning programs, blended learning programs and traditional education programs are faculty and people.  So while important funding decisions do need to be made, these decisions must reflect a better understanding of the cost drivers and the 'average costs' necessary to provide high-quality and cost-efficient online education for all students with people providing support.  Online and blended learning can help students access the best teachers to provide personalized instruction to meet individual student needs."Overall, the focus of our efforts should be on student outcomes, results and success.  State legislators and education policymakers should work to ensure that not only does their funding enable them to provide students with the opportunity to learn online, but also that it provides every student with the opportunity to access a world-class education," Patrick concluded.

No comments:

Post a Comment