Wednesday, October 26, 2011

Keeping Pace with Keeping Pace 2011-2012

Let the data speak for itself.
In autumn, the virtual education community turns its eyes to the Evergreen Education Group for the comprehensive tally of  what's going on in K-12 online learning. The vehicle: electronic and print versions of "Keeping Pace."
This year, the annual compendium is scheduled to be released on Nov. 8. To prime the pump, researchers are promising daily posts with the "top nine" trends they noted as they gathered information for the survey.
"K-12 online and blended learning have evolved in new directions in the past year. While now familiar segments of the field, such as online charter schools and state virtual schools, have continued to grow, relatively new forms such as consortium programs and  single-district programs are expanding even more rapidly, as is the range of private providers competing to work with districts. As of  late 2011, online and blended learning opportunities exist for at least some students in all 50 states plus the District of Columbia,
but no state has a full suite of full-time and supplemental options for students at all grade levels," the researchers wrote in a preliminary post.
No. 1: Online classes in school districts are the fastest growing segment of online and blended learning.
That's right. "Several years ago, state-level and statewide schools and programs were driving most online learning activity. That is no longer the case; now the bulk of activity is at the district level. A second important area of growth is among consortium programs, as districts choose to combine resources to create cost effective online opportunities," according to the Keeping Pace researchers.
No. 2: Most school districts are offering blended, rather than pure virtual or online learning classes.
"A corollary to the growth of district online programs is that many of these options blend online and face to-face learning, instead of being entirely online as many state-level schools were. One reason is simple: Districts are often serving their own students, who are local, so there is limited need to bridge large distance," wrote the Keeping Pace Team.
Click here to read more of Keeping Pace's sneak peek of the top nine trends in online learning.
Liberating Learning will keep pace with the unveiling of the top nine and alert you when they are posted.



Thursday, October 20, 2011

It's a Flipping Controversy

EdSurge got it right. There is a growing debate over the flipped classroom model and it is fascinating to watch this controversy grow.
First, a definition. The Flip Model is being championed by Sal Khan, a former hedge fund analyst who became an accidental education entrepreneur when algebra videos he made to help some cousins went viral.
A flipped approach features a video lecture that the student can watch "any time, any where," let's say at home in place of  traditional homework assignments. This frees classroom time for the teacher to work with individual students or for students to work in teams.
In a article for Education Next, Bill Tucker, managing editor of Education Sector quotes Colorado chemistry teacher Jonathan Bergmann about the flipped method.
"Flipped classroom teachers almost universally agree that it’s not the instructional videos on their own, but how they are integrated into an overall approach, that makes the difference. In his classes, Bergmann says, students can’t just 'watch the video and be done with it.' He checks their notes and requires each student to come to class with a question. And, while he says it takes a little while for students to get used to the system, as the year progresses he sees them asking better questions and thinking more deeply about the
content. After flipping his classroom, Bergmann says he can more easily query individual students, probe for misconceptions around scientific concepts, and clear up incorrect notions."
So why is the flipped method so controversial? Some flip opponents worry about the digital divide.
"Uruguay ranks ahead of the United States in laptop distribution. Maine is the only state to make a significant investment toward ensuring all students even have the computer technology they'd need to watch videos at home. And even giving students laptops doesn't mean they can access the Internet at home. With poverty skyrocketing, some families simply can't afford it," writes Liz Dwyer, education editor of website GOOD.
Dwyer also says, "The other element left out of the flipped classroom discussion is that watching a video is no more active or engaging than reading a textbook. And what happens when a high school student is assigned videos from all six of her classes? Do we really expect students to watch two or three hours of videos at night?"
Vancouver, B.C. teacher David Wees tried the flipped method and decided to drop it.
"Some students chose, despite repeated requests from me, to only watch videos and do exercises that were really easy for them, instead of advancing their knowledge. One student said 'she liked the easy videos because it was easy to get points.' Another student said she chose the easy exercises because 'she was worried about getting problems wrong.' These students were more focused on getting easy
points and avoiding challenges than learning," Wees writes.
Indiana teacher Brian Bennett argues that the flipped method isn't just about the videos.
"The flipped classroom is about making connections with learners and differentiating your instruction. If videos are a part of that multi-faceted plan, great. If they are not, still great. The flipped class is an ideology, not a methodology," Bennett writes.
Bill Tucker, in his Education Next article, seems to summarize the feeling of the moment best.
"Given education’s long history of fascination with new instructional approaches that are later abandoned, there’s a real danger that flipping, a seemingly simple idea that is profound in practice, may be reduced into the latest educational fad. And, in today’s highly polarized political environment, it also runs the risk of being falsely pigeonholed into one of education’s many false dichotomies, such as the age-old pedagogical debate between content knowledge and skills acquisition."

Thursday, October 13, 2011

Part 2: Digital Learning Now's National Report Card on virtual Education Movement


It's no secret in the education reform world that the leadership and supporters of Digital Learning Now spent a lot of time and effort working on legislation that expanded online learning opportunities in Florida, Utah, and Idaho. Digital Learning Now is to be congratulated for helping edtech reformers in those states achieve legislatively.
This is one reason Liberating Learning won't be spotlighting these states in this first look at Digital Learning Now's "National Report Card" on the virtual education movement.
Attention must be paid to what's going on in other states. In Part 1 of these reports, Liberating Learning Twitter followers asked that the spotlight was placed on California, Missouri, New York, Montana and North Carolina.
This time around, the focus will be on Texas, Alaska, Tennessee, Pennsylvania and Ohio.
As in the earlier report, DLN used several methods to characterize the status of digital learning in the states.
Numbers are used to provide a quick view of how DLN sizes up a state--0 is the low, 10 is the high.
DLN also uses labels to characterize the standing of each state when it comes to meeting DLN's "10 Elements."
These "levels of attainment" are:
Achieved: indicates that the state has adopted the measure through law, rule or
indisputable practice.
Partial: indicates the entire range of policies and circumstances between Not Yet and Achieved.
Not Yet: indicates that the state has no policy, a permissive policy that is not effectively achieving the vision or a policy that conflicts with the measure.
If any of this analysis is in dispute, governors and state school chiefs will have until Dec. 31 to challenge DLN's findings.
So here goes:
Texas: Maybe the DLN researchers didn't want to mess with Texas, because there is barely anything in the written synopsis. All they said was, "Texas has the opportunity to lead the nation in transforming education for the digital age," which is the boilerplate language used when the narrative is launched for most of the reviewed states. Numeric scores for Texas range from 0 for "infrastructure" ("Infrastructure supports digital learning"), to 9 for "quality choices" ("All students have access to multiple high quality digital learning providers"). The report card itself is peppered with "achieveds" and "not yets."
Alaska: With its wide open spaces and its vastness, one might assume that Alaska would embrace virtual education as a means to bring quality academics to children, no matter where they live. But according to the DLN researchers, the state is not a leader in online education. It ranks high it having barriers to access to digital education. Alaska lacks the infrastructure to support digital learning and it ranks low in allowing students to progress based on competency. However, Alaska gets an off-the-chart "11" for personalized
learning. Maybe that is a reflection of the state's long-time comfort with correspondence course education. The best the researchers could say was that "a growing number of school districts are offering online and blended options, and the state-level Alaska Virtual Learning Network is creating new opportunities for students."
Tennessee: Another state where the narrative is short, sweet and non-committal. Numeric grades are in the lower reaches. For example, it received a "0" for funding (creating "incentives for performance, options and innovation"). There are more "not yets" than any other comments in the report card.
Pennsylvania: This state has been, will be, and currently is, a hotbed of activity when it comes to virtual education. The PA Cyber Charter is, as the researchers report, "the nation's largest virtual charter." How it is funded, how its student rank on standardized test and what the future holds for it are currently being debated. Local school district throughout Pennsylvania are launching their own online learning programs to lure students--and state education money--away from PA Cyber Charter and back to the districts. With
all of this going on, it's interesting that the DLN researchers gave Pennsylvania low numeric rankings for "quality content," "quality instruction," and 'assessment and accountability." The state did rank high in "quality choices," and "student access."
Ohio: This is another that Digital Learning Now spent time and effort in 2011 to push the virtual education legislative agenda. The effort was somewhat successful with the legislature creating "a task force to identify ways to expand digital learning in the state," according to the DLN narrative. Researchers added: "Watch for a bold reform agenda next legislative session." The state's numeric rankings run from "0" for infrastructure to "8" for "quality choices." A mixed bag for the Buckeye State, but Digital Learning Now believes Ohio is a comer in the online learning world.

Part 1: Digital Learning Now's National Report Card on virtual Education Movement


You definitely need a score card to follow the grading system Digital Learning Now used for its first National Report Card on digital education.
The state-by-state look at the status of digital learning, and the assignment of "grades" to each state is based on 72 metrics developed by Digital Learning Now. These metrics are based on DLN's "10 Elements of High Quality Digital Learning."  These elements,  published last year, were used as the foundation for virtual education legislation from Idaho to Florida. In fact, the 2010 Florida virtual education law was called "The Digital Learning Now Act."
Numbers are used to provide a quick view of how DLN sizes up a state--0 is the low, 10 is the high.
DLN also uses labels to characterize the standing of each state when it comes to meeting DLN's "10 Elements." These "levels of attainment" are:
Achieved: indicates that the state has adopted the measure through law, rule or
indisputable practice.
Partial: indicates the entire range of policies and circumstances between Not Yet and Achieved.
Not Yet: indicates that the state has no policy, a permissive policy that is not effectively achieving the vision or a policy that conflicts with the measure.
If any of this analysis is in dispute, governors and state school chiefs will have until Dec. 31 to challenge DLN's findings.
Why all the emphasis on digital learning. The "Roadmap to Reform," DLN released today says it all.
"Digital learning ensures students are never bored and never left behind. Students who excel in a subject can move ahead academically. Conversely, students who are struggling in a particular subject can spend extra time mastering those skills with guidance from their teacher – either remotely or face-to-face. In schools that adopt blended learning, these students can remain in the same class as their peers even as their individual learning takes them on different paths."
There are some cool features to the online version of the report card. By clicking individual states, the viewer can compare several the results of several states next to each other.
That said, Liberating Learning Twitter followers asked that the results of these states be spotlighted first: California, Missouri, New York, Montana and North Carolina.  Here goes:
California: The Golden State is not so golden when it comes to digital learning. Numeric grades ranged from 0-4. The state received more "not yets" (for example, private school students are eligible for publicly-funded digital learning, home education students are eligible for publicly-funded digital learning, State law ensures publicly-funded digital learning is available for all middle school students) than "achieved" (under state law, district public school students are eligible for publicly-funded digital learning, under state law, charter public school students are eligible for publicly-funded digital learning). DLN researchers added that the state "should repeal regulations that limit online schools to contiguous counties to allow online learning to flourish and expand."
Missouri: Missouri numeric scores run the gamut from 1-10. For infrastructure ("Infrastructure supports digital learning"), 1. But the state received a 10 for "quality of choices" ("All students have access to multiple high quality digital learning providers"). The researchers added the "Missouri has a statewide program for individual online courses from multiple providers, Missouri Virtual Instruction Program.  The program is currently funded by a very low line-item appropriation for students who are medically fragile.  Missouri could exponentially expand its digital learning options by requiring school districts to provide unfettered access to
individual online courses offered by program using existing funding through the per pupil funding formula."
New York: Like so many other states, DLN's researchers wrote that New York has the opportunity to be a leader in the edtech revolution. So far, well, New York's  DLN numeric scores were all three and below. The state got deserved credit for abandoning seat-time rules when it comes to digital courses, but more often than not, the "not yet" label was attached to the survey's metrics. Finally, the reviewers did give a nod to iLearnNYC, which they said, "is offering online and blended courses within the nation’s largest school district."
Montana: Results from this state are a mixed bag. Montana does not authorize charter schools. It does not have a state-led virtual school. But private school and home-schooled students are eligible for publicly-funded digital learning. This is probably the reason Montana's highest numeric score, 5, was for "student access," that is the ability for all students in the state to be "digital learners." The researchers added: "Montana can expand digital learning by opening the state to more providers of digital learning,
including charter schools."
North Carolina: North Carolina has the second largest state virtual school. That would make one think that the state would be in the top echelon of states. According to the DLN research, that's not the case. Digital education "growth slowed this year with the switch from line-item funding to money-follows-the-students," according the researchers. "Removing the ability for school districts to deny access and requiring students to take an online course for graduation could jumpstart enrollment." North Carolina's numeric rankings range from 0-4. There are more "not yet" ranking than "achieved." The researchers did find a bright spot, "a growing number of districts are adding online and blended options."
Stay tuned for Part 2, coming later this afternoon, of this report when five more states will be spotlighted.




How Many Kids are Enrolled in K-12 Virt. Ed. Classes?


The data is starting to roll out of the Foundation for Excellence in Education’s 2011 National Summit on Education Reform in San Francisco. Here's a sneak peek of some of the material in the "Roadmap for Reform."
Using enrollment figures supplied by the sponsors of "Keeping Pace with K12 Online Learning 2011" Digital Learning Now's "Roadmap for Reform" report that for the 2010-2011 school year, there were 217,321 full-time digital learners in the United States and 538,127 part-time digital learners.
These stats are "estimates for the 2010-11 school year, based on the forthcoming (Keeping Pace with K12 Online Learning) report which will be released in November 2011," Digital Learning researchers wrote.
What will be interesting with updated figures--and maybe we won't know until the 2012-2013 enrollment figures are in--is the impact new laws in Utah, Idaho, Florida and other states will have on enrollment growth in blended and virtual education.
For the time being, according to the report, "data includes enrollments in state virtualschools and full-time online schools that operate regionally or across a state, as these are the schools that are typically available to all students in a state. Single district schools are not included.
"For full-time schools, the number is unique students, most of whom take all of their courses from the online school," the Roadmap for Reform report continues. "For state virtual schools, course enrollments, equal to one student taking one semester-long course, are included. Data on blended learning programs is not included.Data on enrollment in individual online courses at the district level is not included."
Click here for the complete report. And stay tuned, Liberating Learning will be spotlighting the Digital Learning Now's "State Digital Learning Report Card" when it is released later today.