Monday, December 20, 2010

2010: Five Important Trends in Virtual Education Movement

Here are five important virtual education trends--not all of them positive--that occurred in 2010. What these issues show is the educational and cultural shift taking place in the United States thanks to technology.
Next week, check Spotlight for the five virtual education issues that are poised to be significant in 2011.
1. Virtual Education goes mainstream. Online learning has played a niche role in the education reform movement. That is no longer the case. From an issue of the New York Times magazine totally devoted to online learning and the issues surround it, to the FCC chairman using his bully pulpit to call for more online education, to two former governors launching the Digital Learning Council, a national advocacy group, attention was paid to virtual education.
According to Keeping Pace, the annual review of virtual education, 48 of 50 states--and the District of Columbia--offer some kind of online learning experience for K-12 students. There is still a long way to go for wider acceptance, but 2010 was a turning point.
2. States tackle funding issues tied to virtual schools. From Oklahoma to Georgia, from Oregon to Texas, per pupil funding of online students in public schools was a red-hot issue. Many legislators saw virtual education as a low-cost means of solving budget problems. This has led many states to low-ball money devoted to virtual schools. There are cost-savings associated with online education, however, low per pupil allocations led school operators in Georgia and Oklahoma to decide not to open already-approved virtual schools.This issue is not going away and the discussion and will increase in intensity in 2011.
3. Mobile devices as educational game-changers. Smartphones. Tablets. Pocket computers such as the iPod Touch. All used for entertainment. All can be used for educational purposes, if school officials change the rules--and their views--governing students' on campus use of this new technology. There are already apps for dictionaries, for flashcards that drill fractions and multiplication tables and much more. Many schools, however, have rules that ban smartphones and iPods. Attitudes are changing. This year was the first that the impact of these device on learning and engagement was widely recognized by educators. Increased acceptance will certainly broaden the "any time, any where" education movement.
4. Seat time vs. mastery of subject debate. If there was once issue in 2010 that showed how education is moving away from the 19th century industrial model to the 21st century information technology model, it was the seat time vs. mastery of subject debate. "Seat time" has long been a mainstay for high school graduation. Basically, it means that to get credits toward a diploma, the student has to spend a certain amount of time seated in a classroom. Online learning allows students to work at their own pace. Smart kids can grasp the basic quickly and move on to more advanced work. Other students can take longer to gain mastery over the same material. Credit for the course is based on mastery of the subject instead of time on task. Customization for each learner so each learner can be successful. If technology can lead to doing away with seat-time rules , the toppling of other antiquated rules will follow.
5. Enrollment caps. Many states that wanted to test online education set enrollment caps for the first wave of schools. This was a way to appease teachers unions, skeptical school administrators and others. What most states found was that enrollment and interest in online education exceeded expectations and the enrollment caps hindered growth of online education. This year was the beginning of the peel-back of enrollment caps. As more states look to online courses as money-savers and as a means to expand curriculum offerings, enrollment caps will be lifted.

Thursday, December 2, 2010

Takeaways from the Digital Learning Council's '10 Elements of High Quality Digital Learning'

It's aspirational. It's detailed. And it just may work.
The Digital Learning Council, the fledgling virtual education policy advocacy group launched earlier this year with former governors Jeb Bush of Florida and Bob Wise of West Virginia at the helm, flexed a mighty muscle when it unveiled its much-anticipated report "Digital Learning Now!" The heart of the report is the "10 Elements of High Quality Digital Learning."
The report is written in plain language with very little pedagogical jargon (there's even a glossary of terms so you can tell the difference between a "state-led online initiatives" and a "full-time online schools").This will be a help to the legislators and policymakers who really [ital] should read this 20-page report.
In an interview with CNN, Bush said it is time to "put digital learning at the core of education rather that at the periphery. Wise stressed that now is the cost effectiveness of virtual education. "Digital learning can also be the catalyst for transformational change in education. It is a tool that can address a myriad of challenges faced by schools, community leaders, and policymakers," according to a statement the former governors signed.

Each of the 10 Elements in the report comes with actions steps that can be used as a sensible guide for lawmakers and policymakers. For example, in the section on student access to technology, action steps include making sure the "state does not restrict access to high quality digital content with policies such as class size ratios and caps on enrollment or budget." Another action step directs states not to restrict access to online classes "based on geography, such as school district, county or state."
A section of the report provides a 10-step program for state leader who want to heighten awareness about virtual education. Bryan Setser, CEO of the North Carolina Virtual Public Schools wrote that he plans to implement five of the steps in the upcoming days, "in an attempt to inspire other principals, superintendents, state virtual school leaders, and policy makers."
Funding, especially how to pay for new education initiatives during a time of national economic distress and belt-tightening, is squarely addressed throughout the Digital Learning Council's report. "To build a quality digital learning environment, states will have to spend smarter--not necessarily more," according the the report's findings.
Paul Peterson, director of Harvard's Program on Education Policy and Governance and a member of the Hoover Institution's Koret K-12 on Education Task Force, says the Learning Council's "most important recommendation has to do with the ways state governments should fund digital learning interventions."

From his perspective, Peterson adds, "Two more elements are needed: Funding should be split among providers, if they are sharing the cost burden. If a student takes a course in a district school from an online provider (say, Apple or Google or the new group Joel Klein is heading up for Rupert Murdoch), then some of the funding should go to the district school, with the balance to the designer of the curriculum. (In Florida, today, funds go either to Florida Virtual School or to the district school—no splitting of funding is possible, an unfortunate impediment to rapid expansion of the on-line learning environment.)

"And, finally, digital learning needs to be transparent and accountable. The public needs to be assured that the student is actually the one who is completing the work for the course, and the public needs to be assured that the course is not only well designed by well executed—without imposing unnecessary restrictions that will impede innovation."
Teachers, and their union reps, should make sure they read "10 Elements." The report calls for more flexibility by teachers' groups and calls on the states to "provide certification reciprocity for online instructors certified by another state," and to create "the opportunity for multi-location
instruction."
"Great teachers produce great students--wherever they live or learn," the report flatly states.
Of course, the report did produce some naysayers. In a post on thequickanded.com, Bill Tucker wrote, "Too often the recommendations assume that quality will naturally result from regulatory relief.
"Quality is an issue to must be faced. "Virtual education is in a time of rapid growth as school districts, for-profit providers, and nonprofit start-ups all move into the online learning world. But without rigorous oversight, a thousand flowers blooming will also yield a lot of weeds," Tucker wrote.
What's next? Expect a full-court press from Digital Learning Council leaders and others in the virtual education movement to get many of the report's recommendations implements. The Digital Learning Council also promises to release a "Report Card on Digital Learning," in October 2011. It will provide a detail state-by-state progress report.