Tuesday, November 9, 2010

Online Students Without Benefits

The benefits referred to in the headline are extracurricular activities.
One of the most voiced concerns adults have when trying to understand taking course online is that the student won't be able to participate in activities--be it sports or the glee club.
For the most part, the adults are right and this is one of the major hurdles virtual education is trying to cross in order to gain mainstream acceptance.
As the home school movement grows in maturity, it has created a network of extracurricular activities for kids who don't have a lot of other kids to pal around with.
Many online school programs are trying to replicate this, but virtual school students who want to play organized high school sports or be part of the mainstream after school science clubs, drama program, or other activities that often help secure college scholarships, are often times just out of luck.
Yeah, being a virtual student who can participate in extracurricular activities at the bricks-and-mortar school down the street is a big deal.
School districts around the country are struggling on how to, or whether to, accommodate the virtual student. The debate in one Arizona school district is emblematic of the current debate.
In Glendale, Ariz., which is just outside Phoenix, the Peoria Unified School District Board of Education unanimously voted against allowing virtual education students in its district--no matter if these students were taking virtual classes as part of district programs--to participate in district-sponsored extracurricular activities.
The fall 2010 vote came after the the Arizona Interscholastic Association, a group of public and private high schools that supervises interscholastic activities, came to the district with a proposal for a one-year pilot program that would allow online charter students to play in AIA-sanctioned sports.
Following the pilot, the AIA will determine whether the program should be continued.
According to azcentral.com, Peoria board president Kathy Knecht said to allow participation might encourage more students to take all of their schooling at online charter schools.
Knecht said she is not in favor of students going full-time at online charters because they would miss out on social activities.
Another Peoria school district board member, Hal Borhauer, was interested in participating in a pilot program because he saw it as a possible recruiting school that would entice Arizona students outside of the district to attend the Peoria online charter school. However, Borhauer voted against participating in the pilot program because, according to azcentral.com, because the school district would not receive any additional state money for virtual school students who participated in after-school activities.
The Peoria district could charge a fee to virtual students participating in extracurricular activities, but any state attendance funding the students attached to the students would still go to the virtual charter school, not the brick-and-mortar school activity is based.
"Online charter school students should live with the consequences of their choice and that is not having the opportunity to participate in district sports," Mike Maas, the district's administrator for support services told azcentral.com.
Maas also was reported as telling the board that full-time district students could get bumped out of spots on a team by online charter students. He suggested online charter schools could establish their own sports teams and activities, or the online charter students could find other alternatives, such as joining clubs or youth sports groups.
That is just what is happening in many places.
Minnesota is just one of the states where parochial schools are seeking cyber school students to join their students in sports leagues.
School districts in other states are allowing virtual school students to join their bricks-and-mortar peers in after school programs.
For example, in October 2010, the Waynesboro, Va. School Board unanimously voted to offer a virtual high school program to its students, and at the same time, directed district officials to allow students attending the virtual high school the right to participate in all of the extracurricular activities offered at the bricks-and-mortar high school.
In Casper, Wyo., the Natrona County School District School Board gave the OK to virtual school students participate in after-school programs, but there is a catch.
Students attending the Natrona County School district's virtual high school can participate in the district's after school activities. Virtual school students taking online classes through another district's virtual school aren’t eligible to participate in extracurricular activities.
In Oklahoma, it took a state law to make sure that virtual education students had equal access to extracurricular activities. A June 5, 2010 law allows any Oklahoma students to enroll in a virtual education program. The law also allows full-time online learners to participate fully in extracurricular activities with nearby public schools.

Wednesday, November 3, 2010

First Look at How Election Results Impact Virtual Ed. Movement

The virtual education movement wasn't on any ballot in this midterm election, but it was raised as a campaign issue in a number of states and by many candidates.
And while the dust is still settling, here is a quick look at some of the races where virtual education played a significant role.
First, let's take a look at three races for the governor's office.
In Florida, Republican Rick Scott was elected. During the campaign, Scott was emphatic for his support of expanding the state's leadership in K-12 virtual education.
Republican Susana Martinez, was elected and will become New Mexico's first Latina chief executive, is another advocate of virtual education. During the campaign, she said said she supported giving students and their families the opportunity of "school choice," which she defined that as giving families the opportunity to choose whether to attend their neighborhood public school or a charter school, vocational school, or a virtual classroom.
Texas Republican Gov. Rick Perry was re-elected. Perry pledged that in the 2011 legislative session he will lead the charge to expand the Virtual School Network (VSN) to create the Texas Virtual High School that will provide students who have dropped out of school an opportunity to earn a high school diploma through virtual courses, while improving access to high-quality courses for all students.
The future of virtual education was also an important issue in the election of school superintendent's office.
For example, in Idaho, schools chief Tom Luna was re-elected. Online schools have grown in size and number during Luna's term. His race attracted a $25,000 donation from K12 Inc., a for-profit, technology-based education company that offers curriculum and educational services. K12's donation went to an independent group called "Idahoans for Choice in Education."
That group turned around and gave $25,000 to an "Arizona firm to handle broadcast advertising and production in an independent campaign supporting the re-election of" of Luna, according to the Idaho Spokesman-Review.
Over in Wisconsin, Republican Sam Hagedorn, who said he got into the race for the 12 Assembly seat because he was "tired of the current office holder trying to kill the Milwaukee Voucher Program along with charter and virtual schools," was defeated by incumbent Democrat Frederick P. Kessle.
Finally, one of the most important ballot measures for the virtual education movement was Florida's Amendment 8, which failed. If it had been approved, Amendment 8 would have loosened strict class-size limits. The restrictions on class size, which have been phased in since 2002, were abruptly felt this fall. School administrators faced large fines if they did not meet the requirements.
One of the unexpected benefits of Amendment 8 was that it provided school officials to direct more students to online classes, which do have any size limitations.
Stay tuned. As the results and trends become clearer, we will return to see how the virtual education movement fared in the November 2010 midterm election.