Wednesday, September 29, 2010

Will E-Rate Mobile Device Experiment Loosen School Rules on Cellphones?

And a child shall lead them. In this case, it is a generation of children who are in the lead and may ultimately force policy changes on the use of cellphones and mobile devices on school campuses.
When talking about the Federal Communications Commission's recent policy changes for its E-Rate program, FCC Chairman Julius Genachowski credited student mobile phone use
for inspiring the commission to create and fund a pilot program to demonstrate how mobile devices can be turned into everyday learning tools.
"Early experimentation demonstrates the potential of on-the-go learning. In Onslow County, N.C., in an experimental program supported by Qualcomm, high school students were given smartphones with 24/7 Internet access. The students who were taught math on these learning devices were more likely to achieve proficiency in Algebra than classmates who had the same teacher but weren't given phones," Genachowski told a Silicon Valley audience.
Gaining widespread acceptance of mobile technology as an educational tool is easier said than done. Most schools, such as Lincoln East High School in Lincoln, Neb., ban the use of mobile
devices during the school and on school grounds. Educators say there are many reasons for these bans: the devices are distracting, they can be used to cheat, and there is no real educational value to them.
This attitude may be changing.
At Burlington High in Massachusetts, using mobile devices during the day as educational tools is encouraged.
Technology "raise expectations of ourselves" and changes the way we do things, Burlington High Principal Patrick Larkin told the Boston Globe. "It’s a different mindset."
While adults continue debating the educational benefits of mobile devices, the children are leading.
In response to a New York Times blog post asking "Can Cellphones be Educational Tools?" Students responded with a ranges of examples, everything from using calendars to organize homework assignments to using calculators to texting questions to teachers and answering online polls posted by teachers.
Experiments such as the one in Onslow, N.C. and the E-Rate demonstration
model may help to change the minds of educators. The tech world is hopeful and watching.
"Hats off the the FCC for modernizing E-Rate," wrote syndicated tech columnist Larry Magid. "Now let's hope schools modernize their attitude toward the use of technology to embrace rather than try to block some of the technologies students are using in their daily lives.

Wednesday, September 22, 2010

Different Views of Silicon Valley 'Digital Learning' Conference

For one brief shining moment, Silicon Valley became the center of the virtual education movement world. At least that what it seems like after reading several of the reports from the "Back to School: Learning and Growing in a Digital Age,” a one-day conference held in the Computer History Museum in Mountain View.
Among the writers covering the meeting, there appears to be no doubt on who was the star of the day: Federal Communications Chairman Julius Genachowski. Karen Cator, director of Education Technology for the U.S. Department of Education, was a close second.
The eschool News article gives a straight-ahead, chronological accounting of the conference opening, which featured James P. Steyer, CEO and founder, Common Sense Media, one of the event's sponsors, and keynote remarks by Genachowski.
Ian Quillen, who writes and blogs for Education Week's Digital Directions, focused on Genachowski's prediction that proposed changes to the FCC's E-Rate Program will approved soon.
San Jose Mercury News tech columnist Mike Cassidy, wondered how a nation mired in the greatest recession since the 1930s will be able to afford the money needed for all of the gee-whiz gadgetry Genachowski and other panelists said are needed to create the 21st century classroom.
MindShift's Tina Barseghian totally ignored the first panel and Genachowski. Instead, she wrote about the second discussion "Empowering Parents and Kids with Technology." Her report
did catch one of the conference's undercurrents: how big tech companies--Google, Yahoo, Facebook and others--were there emphasizing how to make social media safe for school use. Maybe these firms are gearing up for the next hurdle in front of wider integration of Internet use in schools.

Tuesday, September 7, 2010

Seat Time vs. Mastery of Subject

The next big battle in the virtual education movement may be over seat time. The first skirmishes are occurring in an area where virtual education is racking up some of its biggest successes--online credit recovery programs.

First, a glossary of terms. "Seat time" is a requirement that has long been a mainstay for high school graduation. Basically, it means that to get credits toward a diploma, the student has to spend a certain amount of time seated in a classroom. Typically, it is 120 hours for each high school credit. However, many online credit recovery courses--aimed at non-traditional students or students who have not passed the course in a traditional campus setting--offer students credit if he or she demonstrates mastery of the subject. How much time the student spends online doesn't matter.

Recently in Georgia, parents and online educators called on the state board of education to drop seat time requirements and give online students the freedom to "move on when ready."

"The notion that students should have to sit in a chair for a certain amount of time when it's only a certain aspect of algebra they don't get baffles me," says Carmita P. Vaughn, the chief strategy officer for the America's Promise Alliance, a Washington, D.C.-based nonprofit partnership whose goal is to improve high school graduation rates.

Kathy Christie, the chief of staff for the Denver-based Education Commission of the States told Education Week. "To work off of a proficiency base allows kids to accelerate. It allows them to make up for bad decisions. It keeps they on the prize for kids: 'These are the standards. These are the things I need to know.' "

In the 2009 report, "21st Century Learning Environments," researchers argue that schools cannot continue to use seat time as a measure of academic attainment. Instead, measures of learning must include thoughtful assessments of a student’s ability to apply and demonstrate
knowledge in complex situations.

What do teachers think? In a 2009 blog post, Colorado classroom teacher Michael Mazenko probably speaks for many when he writes, "I have come to question the concept of "seat time" or "contact hours" in public education, and I am more intrigued by a focus on accomplishment of core competencies."