Tuesday, May 31, 2011
Virtual Education Spring
Well, attention must be paid to the U.S. education policy and political community where people in dozens of states have dismantled long-held education policies to create a "virtual education spring."
This wave of change has occurred from Alabama, where legislators changed laws that forced virtual charter schools to operate from physical buildings, to West Virginia, where the state board of education adopted Digital Learning Now's "10 Elements of High Quality Digital Learning" as part of the state's "Global21" learning plan.
Utah approved several bills that will expand online learning opportunities in the state. Florida, already a leader in the virtual education movement, created an open marketplace where parents and educators can all have equal access to for-profit, not-profit and public providers of online courses.
"It's pretty unprecedented, when you take a look at how much education legislation has been enacted around the country," Patrick McGuinn, an associate professor of political science and education at Drew University in Madison, N.J. told Education Week as he described a wide range of education reforms, including ones centered on virtual education, approved by state legislatures so far this year.
To be sure, not every virtual education measure has moved smoothly through state legislatures. Oregon virtual education proponents are in a bitter battle with the state's largest teachers union over a union-back bill virtual education proponents say will create a huge bureaucracy that will crush, and eventually kill, virtual charter schools in the state.
The Georgia State Supreme Court handed down a ruling that struck down a law empowering the Georgia Charter Schools Commission to approve and finance charter schools, even if local school districts declined to back the charter. Virtual school supporters fear this will close schools already in operation and eliminate the possibility of creation new virtual and charter schools. Virtual and charter community supporters have asked the Georgia court to review its decision.
In Idaho, the fight over launching edtech-center reforms became blood sport. After a bare-knuckled fight, three bills were signed into law which shifted money from teachers salaries to tech upgrades for schools, created a merit-pay program for teachers, and eliminated most teacher collective bargaining rights. Opponents launched a petition drive to overturn the changes through a referendum. The opponents also targeted Idaho schools chief Tom Luna, who led the reform movement, for recall.
Reform opponents claim they have enough signatures to place a referendum on the reforms on the ballot.
Even with these challenges, virtual education and incorporating digital tools to create instruction innovation, is gaining momentum.
For example, in Pennsylvania, a growing number of school districts are preparing to open cyber charter schools as a way to attract students who left their local districts to attend statewide cyber charters. The local districts are doing this to bring state money that underwrites the cyber charter students back to their home districts.
The National Association of Secondary School Principals recently issued a call for greater access to and wider acceptance of technologies such as social networks, smart phones, and mobile devices in classrooms.
According to T.H.E. Journal, the principals group executive director Gerald. N. Tirozzi, indicated that blocking these technologies takes education in the wrong direction.
"It's becoming increasingly clear that simply blocking such technologies does students a disservice," Tirozzi said. "An education that fails to account for the responsible use of mobile devices and social networks prepares students for our past, but not for their future."
Wednesday, May 4, 2011
Digital Learning Now: Online Education's Impact Player
In less than a year, Digital Learning Now has become an important catalyst in the virtual education policy arena.
The goal of Digital Learning Now, found in August 2010 as the Digital Learning Council, is to provide a road map for lawmakers and policy shapers to follow when developing legislation and polices that encourage the growth of online learning.
The group's narrow focused has worked. It's impact can be seen in statehouses, where legislators quote Digital Learning Now's "10 Elements of High Quality Digital Learning" and incorporate many of the elements into legislation.
Public policy analysts have used DLN's elements as the core to build reports and studies on virtual education. Laws expanding online learning opportunities approved this year in Utah and Idaho include parts of DLN's elements. What's more, when it looked as if these laws were likely not to get out of the legislative bodies, DLN leaders and supporters launched successful efforts to get the bills approved on the governors' desks for signing.
And if imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, Florida legislators wisely changed the name of a floundering bill from CS/CS/HB 7197 to the "Digital Learning Now Act." The name change, some say helped change the bill's fortunes because it got the needed votes for passage in the Florida House of Representatives.
Simply put, DLN's "10 Elements of High Quality Digital Learning" has become the equivalent of the Good Housekeeping Seal of Approval when it comes to legislation aimed at expanding K-12 online education opportunities.
Why has Digital Learning Now been so effective so quickly?
- The face, really the faces, of the organization are two former governors that, when their names are linked, say bipartisan. Former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush, a Republican, and former West Virginia Gov. Bob Wise, a Democrat, immediately get door open when they talk to the current crop of governors and state lawmakers. In addition, the 100 original signatories of the Digital Learning Council policy proclamation represent a broad spectrum of influential leaders in politics, education and business.
- The narrow focus on education reform policy at the state level. The guiding principles make no bones about it, DLN's 10 elements "are directed toward state laws and policies." They are written in a way the make it easy for legislators and their staff to blend DLN's elements into a legislative mold.
- The harmonic convergence of public acceptance of tech advancement, an economic downturn that left states looking for new funding solutions and good, old-fashion political influence (often provided by Bush and Wise.) DLN says it best, "Growing budget deficits and shrinking tax revenue present a tremendous challenge for the nation's governors and lawmakers ... However, what might appear to be an obstacle to reform can also present a great opportunity for innovation."
Bush, Wise and their DLN support team have spent their first year holding forums, getting op-eds published, backing online petitions, getting legislation written, approved and signed into law and, when necessary, using political muscle, to reach their goals.
To be sure, everyone is not enamored with DLN.
"There seems to be missing an appreciation for the value of the human and personal community which has always been a central crux of learning. Shouldn’t there be recommendations that states and districts support on-line learners with opportunities and programs for athletics, for performing arts, for in-person mentoring, coaching, and counseling?" Jonathan Martin wrote in 2010 on the 21K12 blog.
"Don’t we have to strive for a balance where we harness the best of the digital tools with the best of traditional practices, in which caring and inspirational adults can elicit the best efforts and warmly provide the best counsel?" he asked.
Next up for DLN is a national report card. In October, the organization plans to participate in a national summit on education reform in San Francisco. One of the components of the meeting will be a report card that grades each state on how it is nurturing digital learning based on the 10 elements.