Monday, February 7, 2011

Digital Textbooks at the Tipping Point?

No money for new textbooks. That's the reason so many states and school districts are seriously looking to to use digital textbooks--and e-readers--in more elementary, middle and high school classrooms.
If the talk turns into action, the widespread introduction of digital textbooks would reduce costs facing now cash-strapped states and school districts. It also would force schools to embrace digital media as a regular classroom learning tool.
“I think the idea of digital media replacing traditional textbooks is definitely part of the future. There’s definitely movement in that
direction," says Jeff Mao, learning technology director at the Maine Department of Education, is vice chairman of the State Educational Technology Directors Association board of directors. Mao told keepmecurrent.com there are times when books are better, but with the outpouring of new e-readers which realistically mimic the pages of a book and more powerful handheld devices like netbooks, Mao sees general acceptance of digital textbooks as a logical next step.
From Georgia, to Missouri and Wisconsin to Texas, Florida, and California, the debate over digital textbooks and e-readers has been pushed to the forefront by the need to find new, lower-cost ways to underwrite public education.
In addition, how 21st century students read, write and communicate has changed and educators say the means to reach these students must change, too. In Maine's Sanford schools, textbooks are still in the classrooms, but students pick them up less often as technology takes
over.
Assistant Superintendent David Theoharides told keepmecurrent.com that in many cases, students have been using computers as a supplement to their textbooks.
For additional help with their algebra homework, for instance, students may be able to visit an algebra website sponsored by the textbook companies, Theoharides said. Some of these websites even have an online chalkboard with a teacher’s voice for guidance.
Though technology hasn’t replaced textbooks yet, these online resources may one day help schools save on pricey textbooks that can cost as much as $30 to $40 each.
“I’ve seen a trend around the schools where we send textbooks home less and less,” said Theoharides. “If it’s a way to save some funds and still give students these resources that would be great.”
In West Virgina, a $271 million plan to move classrooms from print textbooks to digital texts has been met with skepticism, especially from classroom teachers who say that the goal of equal access to technology is not within the reach of many students, let alone school
campuses.
"I am a social studies teacher and I am avidly against this," freshman West Virgina Delegate Brian Savilla told the Dominion Post. Many families can't afford school lunch, he said, so how are they going to afford Internet hookups in their homes?
And in his classroom with 26 "computers on wheels," he's never had all of them working at once. Not to mention the need for batteries and power outlets to charge the machines, plus power cords strewn across classroom floors.
"There's all these little holes in the plan that don't add up," he said.
Backers of digital textbooks say that hurdles can, and will be, crossed. Once digital textbooks are more widely available, the sooner teachers can start capturing the imaginations of a new generation.
Maine's learning technology director Jeff Mao uses the example of the Battle of Gettysburg to illustrate the difference between traditional and digital textbooks.
A paper textbook, he says, is limited in its presentation. There may be a few pictures, a few charts, a few perspectives on the battle. But a digital device could offer that plus embedded links offering curious students an endless supply of Internet sites addressing facets of
the battle. It would be the teacher’s or curriculum coordinator’s job to corral the infinite segues into a package presentable on the laptop.“
Here in Maine, we would want to have a special focus on Joshua Chamberlain’s role in the battle,” Mao told keepmecurrent.com. “A textbook might give you a paragraph if you’re lucky, but online content would offer much more, perhaps a map of where Chamberlain was positioned with elevation, where the guns were, where the soldiers were arrayed, perhaps re-creations of the battle in audio, video, interactive live data, blogs. The
content could be endless.”
“Converting to digital content is something that could not only save money but have learning benefits, as well,” Mao said.

No comments:

Post a Comment