Thursday, January 20, 2011

Will Class Size Requirements End Virtually?

It has been the holy grail of education for decades: Small is beautiful. Small classes, that is.
This all may be changing. Government budget constraints, the decline in the power of public employee unions, and the growing move to online instruction are the reasons.
Last year, according to Stateline.org, 11 states relaxed class-size requirements either through legislative action or administratively.
Texas plans to allow more students in each classroom and Idaho’s state superintendent proposed boosting average class sizes as a means to which would eliminate 770 teaching jobs save $514 million over five years.
In 2009, in California, school officials deferred funding for a program that sent state money to school districts to shrink classes in kindergarten through third grade. The state relaxed penalties to districts that did not comply with the reductions. In 2010, Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger cut another $550 million from the class-size reduction program, Stateline.org reported.
In the 2010 election, a Florida ballot measure asked voters if they wanted to repeal a 2002 constitutional amendment setting class-size caps. The measure won 55 percent of the statewide vote, but that was short of the 60 percent required to overturn a constitutional amendment.
Meeting the restrictions put many Florida districts in a corner. The law fines school districts up to $3,000 for each additional student in classes that exceed the mandated maximum. Palm Beach County already owes the state $16.6 million in fines.
Florida state school officials are considering reducing or eliminating the fines, and lawmakers are looking for a legislative solution. Some districts have threatened to sue over the fines.
To meet class size requirements, many Florida schools are assigning students to online classes, which do not have a size limit. A New York Times article lamented that 7,000 Miami-Dade students were in classes "without teachers." This infuriated people closer to the situation.
"In fact, kids taking a Florida Virtual School class do have a state-certified teacher overseeing their work and conversing with them on a regular basis," a columnist with the Orlando Sentinel wrote. " Students can call their teachers between 8 a.m. and 8 p.m. during the week. Virtual school teachers regularly visit the schools that offer the e-labs mentioned in the article. None of this was in the story because it contradicts the story line."
"I certainly read and respect the NY Times. But this was lazy and slipshod reporting," the columnist added.
Many state officials say that loosening statewide class size restrictions gives local districts more leeway to manage difficult budget situations.
“You’re untying the hands of local districts,” says Clara Keith, Georgia’s associate superintendent for school improvement.
Some local school administrators, however, see that as a way to move difficult decisions out of state jurisdiction and onto the individual school districts.
Still, backers of larger class sizes,are finding some support from Washington. U.S. Education Secretary Arne Duncan, in a speech in November, noted that many high-performing school systems in Asia have larger classes than the United States and urged school districts to consider raising class sizes, at least in the higher grades.
“In secondary schools,” he said, “districts may be able to save money without hurting students, while allowing modest but smartly targeted increases in class size.”
Most teacher unions favor small classes. But their reasons are quickly becoming overshadowed by mounting state and local budget deficits. The more the unions dig their heels in on this issue, the more they seem to be out of touch with a recession ravaged public.
"The growing discrepancy between conditions in the public and private sectors has eroded much of the sympathy public-sector workers might once have enjoyed," according to an article in The Economist titled, Public-sector unions have had a good few decades. Has their luck run out? The technological advances that allow students to take courses at their own pace, supervised by online and in-classroom teachers is a force in the move toward loosening class size rules. According to a report by Ambient Insight Research, "the disproportionately high growth of
self-paced e-learning in preK-12 is being driven in large part by four factors: the "rapid growth of virtual schools, the dramatic increase in online students, the recession, and state budget cuts," the last of which is causing schools to shift budgets from programs like classroom-based summer credit recovery courses to self-paced courses."
The market for online course will only grow, the report adds. David Nagel, a blogger with the Transforming Education Through Technology Journal points out that Ambient "researchers noted that overall numbers of preK-12 students attending physical classrooms only will decline
(by 4.2 percent) by 2015, while the population begins to migrate to virtual schools, online charter schools, and online supplemental instruction. More than 10 million students will participate in some amount of online supplemental instruction by 2015, up from 2010 levels
of 2.9 million, for a compound annual growth rate of 28 percent. More dramatic growth will be seen in online charter schools and virtual schools."
The number of students in a class is an emotional issue. Parents, as well as teachers, are some of the strongest proponents for small classes. It was a parent/teacher coalition that stopped the 2010 Florida ballot measure from being approved.
That said, budgetary and technological times have changed and this may lead to class size changes. For example, the Texas comptroller’s proposal would amend the law to say that elementary classes must average 22 students across a district, rather than using 22 students as a hard cap for every classroom. Texas state Senator Florence Shapiro, who chairs the Senate education committee says the change would give local school officials more flexibility.
“The number 22-to-one was an arbitrary number,” according to Shapiro. “It was really put in place at a time when we thought smaller class sizes were the most important element in the classroom. Today, I believe the most important element in the classroom is the teacher.”

No comments:

Post a Comment